Another year, another Oscars. With less diversity, but still some excellent storytelling. We can't have it all, folks. Let's dive into it and see what we got this year!
Best Picture: We've got another wide-ranging set of movies, covering a slew of genres, making it an even more ridiculous exercise to say that one of these was "Best" when they are all so audaciously different from each other. But my pick is
The Brutalist. This movie was unfathomably astonishing, and I know that it's fashionable for people who haven't seen it to quibble about its three-and-a-half-hour runtime, but just give it a shot. This movie is sublime, earns that runtime, and absolutely deserves all the kudos it is receiving. Next up, I would say that
Anora and
Conclave are tied for my affections. These movies feature crackling performances and propulsive plots that kept me on the edge of my seat up until the very end. And then we have
Nickel Boys,
I'm Still Here, and
The Substance, three films that remind us of why we need more gender and racial diversity in film, both in front of and behind the camera. These are great films, tackling very different subjects, but approaching them from a unique, often mind-bending perspective, and wholly immersing the audience in the characters. Then we get to the two musicals,
Wicked and
A Complete Unknown. Wicked is the better movie, a complete package featuring excellent music, production design, and performances, while A Complete Unknown is a thin biopic that shines in terms of the performances from Timothee Chalamet and Monica Barbaro. And yes, there is a third musical, the chaotic
Emilia Perez, but the less said about that the better. That movie has had a true fall from grace over the course of its Oscar campaign and is destined to become a laughable footnote in cinematic history. And then, we have
Dune: Part Two as our final nominee. Listen, I don't know why this movie is nominated for Best Picture - it was a spectacle, sure, but this is clearly just a plea to get more audience viewership for the Oscars by nominating some big box office films. Let's move along.
Best Director: Coralie Fargeat has nabbed the one nomination for a woman in this category, for her truly visionary work in The Substance. While I thought the movie was spectacular and she is clearly a force to be reckoned with, I loved The Brutalist too much and am rooting for Brady Corbet to win this award instead. Fresh off a DGA win, however, Sean Baker might end up as the winner for Anora; he has rapidly become one of my favorite directors, so I wouldn't be mad about this win, but oh, poor Brady Corbet. And...no to James Mangold for A Complete Unknown or Jacques Audiard for Emilia Perez. Mangold is a journeyman director who put in serviceable work, but this is a pretty basic movie, while Audiard is an example of why we need someone other than a white man behind the camera when telling a movie about Mexican folks. RaMell Ross should have been nominated here instead, for his truly remarkable work on Nickel Boys, but alas. We'll have to give him his Oscar some other year.
Best Actress: Well, we know Karla Sofia Gascon will not be winning for Emilia Perez, so let's quickly dispense with that. While Cynthia Erivo put in phenomenal work in Wicked, she is going to have to just be happy to be nominated this year. Which leaves us with Mikey Madison for Anora, Demi Moore for The Substance, and Fernanda Torres for I'm Still Here. I loved all three of these performances, but I will have to personally root for Demi Moore just because it would be a fitting tribute to her long "popcorn movie" career. Madison has plenty of time to earn another nomination, but Torres is a worthy opponent for Moore who may never have a second chance at this, so I won't begrudge her if she nabs the trophy instead.
Best Actor: This is an interesting category. I love Colman Domingo and wish he would win an Oscar already, but
Sing Sing didn't move me as much as it did other people, and he does not seem to have much of a shot of getting up on that stage this year. Timothee Chalamet was fantastic in A Complete Unknown and put in so much work that I honestly would enjoy seeing him walk away with a statue. Adrien Brody was superb in The Brutalist, and while I loved his performance, the man already has an Oscar so why can't he share the wealth? Interestingly, Brody was the youngest man to win Best Actor in 2003 for The Pianist but if Chalamet wins, he will snatch that record from Brody. Doesn't that feel fitting? Of course, he also has stiff competition from Ralph Fiennes for Conclave and Sebastian Stan for
The Apprentice. I was surprised to discover Fiennes has never won an Oscar before, but this will still not be his year. Stan has been putting in remarkable work this year, but he will probably have to wait his turn like everyone else.
Best Supporting Actress: Zoe Saldana is the shoo-in here for Emilia Perez. She delivers a powerhouse performance that is by no means "Supporting," but I guess we'll play this game. I was truly delighted to see Monica Barbaro's nomination here for A Complete Unknown, because I was worried people were giving Chalamet all the kudos for his work as Bob Dylan and neglecting to acknowledge her work as Joan Baez. She won't be winning this year, but hopefully she will now have many future chances to win an award. Ariana Grande was wonderful in Wicked, but this is not her year - maybe she'll have a shot next year with the sequel! Felicity Jones has a meaty role in The Brutalist, but she can't quite eclipse her competitors in this category. And Isabella Rossellini is barely even in Conclave - this is a truly Judi Dench-esque Supporting performance, and she will not be winning for it.
Best Supporting Actor: Kieran Culkin is going to walk away with this one for his incredible work on
A Real Pain, and it is rightfully deserved, even though, this is very much a Best Actor performance and not "Supporting" in any way. I was personally delighted to see Yura Borisov nominated for his work in Anora where he does more acting with his soulful eyes than anyone else and I was a complete sucker for it. Jeremy Strong and Guy Pearce deliver strong performances as hateful, powerful men in The Apprentice and The Brutalist, respectively, but an award seems unlikely. And while Edward Norton is wonderful as Pete Seeger in A Complete Unknown, he simply does not have a shot this year. Better luck next year, gentlemen.
Best Original Screenplay: Anora just won the WGA award, so that dizzyingly entertaining and endearing script is likely the frontrunner. But the first time I saw The Brutalist, I genuinely thought it was a true story - doesn't that deserve something? And
September 5, which is not nominated for anything else, has a taut and brilliant script that I dearly loved. And then A Real Pain and The Substance are equally brilliant and creative and wild in their own ways. My God. This is a thoroughly stacked category where I'm hoping for a five-way tie - can we make that happen please?
Best Adapted Screenplay: Nickel Boys won the WGA award, and I'm certainly rooting for them to win the trophy here. No to Emilia Perez (boooo!). I loved Conclave, so it's probably my runner-up in this category. Sing Sing would be a very deserving winner, but I don't think it has a shot, while A Complete Unknown was just another humdrum biopic and doesn't need to be winning here.
That's all for the major categories. There has been a lot of back-and-forth in the precursor award shows and it's not clear who the real frontrunner is - Anora has been staging a massive comeback, and The Brutalist seems to be increasingly sidelined, but I do hope they can each divvy up a slew of awards as they were two of my favorite films this year. That being said, I loved many of these movies and performances, so this is a year when I'll truly just be happy with whoever wins. Except Emilia Perez. Boof.